Search
Amid a landscape of evolving financial rules, regional banks across the United States are joining forces to navigate a more complex regulatory environment. This wave of consolidation marks a pivotal moment for community lenders and their customers.
In September 2024, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) finalized a rule that amended the Bank Merger Act, introducing additional regulatory hurdles for community banks. By removing expedited reviews and streamlined applications, the OCC effectively slowed down the merger process, prompting many smaller institutions to reconsider standalone strategies.
Under the new framework, regulators assess multiple dimensions of a proposed merger. Key factors in the OCC’s review include:
The combination of these requirements has driven up legal and compliance expenditures, making smaller institutions particularly vulnerable.
By May 2025, bipartisan momentum emerged to roll back the OCC’s 2024 rule. Both the House and Senate passed legislation, led by Rep. Andy Barr and Sen. John Kennedy, that would reverse the added complexities imposed on bank mergers. President Donald Trump is expected to sign the bill into law, framing the move as a victory for regional lenders.
Concurrently, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) rescinded its 2024 Statement of Policy on merger transactions, reinstating the prior guidelines. This reversal signals the FDIC’s intent to foster robust competition and local choice by alleviating what critics call unnecessary bureaucratic barriers.
Beyond regulatory catalysts, regional banks face growing commercial challenges. Over recent years, banks have contended with rising costs tied to:
In this climate, consolidating with a peer or acquiring a smaller rival can yield scale efficiencies in technology, staffing, and capital management. Many executives view combinations as a pathway to build sophisticated reporting infrastructure and to strengthen balance sheets against macroeconomic headwinds.
Industry data illustrates a steady climb in announced regional bank mergers, from roughly 20 deals in 2021 to an estimated 45 in 2024. The heightened activity reflects banks’ desire to pool resources and reduce unit costs.
While consolidation can deliver stronger capital buffers, it also raises concerns about reduced local choice. Community advocates worry that mergers may centralize decision-making and undercut personalized banking relationships in rural areas. As one state banker put it, “We must ensure healthy community banking ecosystems endure even as institutions combine.”
Views vary across the sector. The American Bankers Association praises legislative rollbacks as essential to maintaining competitiveness against large national banks. Meanwhile, the Conference of State Bank Supervisors argues that federal overreach had made healthy deals more cumbersome, especially for small-town lenders.
Lawmaker voices emphasize balance. Rep. Barr notes that removing ‘‘unnecessary guardrails’’ will bolster local credit availability, whereas some consumer groups caution against unchecked consolidation and advocate for protections that preserve community lending mandates.
With regulatory barriers easing, the question becomes whether merger activity will accelerate further—and how swiftly the industry adapts. Analysts point to several key uncertainties:
As the sector moves forward, regional banks must strike a balance between achieving scale and preserving the relationships that define community banking. The next chapter in this consolidation story will determine whether policy changes translate into sustainable growth and stronger support for local economies.
References
